Mother Gabley of King’s Lynn: Witchcraft, Fear and a Storm off the Norfolk Coast
Among King’s Lynn’s darker fragments of memory sits the story of Mother Gabley (or Gably, or Gable) as the records variously style her. She is presented in museum leaflets and ghost walks as the old woman whose cauldron of eggs shook the sea itself, drowning sailors returning from Spain in 1583. Behind that vivid tale lies a spare parish note, a shift in English law, and the anxieties of a maritime world that could not bear randomness.
A Law that Shifted Blame onto Ordinary People
In 1563 Queen Elizabeth’s government enacted the statute “Against Conjurations, Enchantments and Witchcrafts”. Homicide by sorcery became legally equivalent to murder and therefore punishable by hanging. Before that date, witchcraft accusations tended to be the province of church courts or political manoeuvring against the elite. The change drew accusations down into the world of common folk. Cunning women who sold herbal remedies, widows who relied upon neighbours’ charity, or those who simply looked odd could become targets.
Norfolk was particularly exposed. Its economy lived or died by the sea. Ships bound for the Low Countries or Spain sailed from Lynn, Yarmouth and smaller creeks along the coast. When storms struck, neither theology nor meteorology offered satisfying explanations. Witchcraft did. It personalised disaster.
The December Wreck and an Extraordinary Note
“This year were drowned in the sea six men of this parish, which deaths were brought to pass by the detestable workings of an execrable witch of King’s Lynn, whose name was Mother Gabley. She, by boiling (or rather labouring) of certain eggs in a pail of cold water, did in a miraculous manner raise up a tempest whereby the said persons were cast away. She was afterwards taken and executed for the same.”
Source: Wells-next-the-Sea Parish Register, PD 679/1 (Norfolk Records Office)
The Wells-next-the-Sea parish register for 1583 carries one of the most remarkable marginal remarks ever written in a Norfolk burial book. It records several drowning burials, then adds that their deaths were brought to pass by the workings of a King’s Lynn witch of whose name was Mother Gabley, achieved by “the boylyng or rather labouring of certayn eggs in a payle full of colde water”.
That single sentence is the kernel from which centuries of retelling have grown. It links a storm at sea to behaviour supposedly witnessed in Lynn at the same moment. Contemporary names survive for at least four of the drowned men: Robert Archer, Oliver Cobb, William Barrett and Henry Goldsmith among them, with later writers assuming thirteen in total because folklore likes symmetry. Whether coincidence or embellishment, the report identifies both culprit and ritual.
The egg detail mattered. Ovomancy is one of the oldest and most widespread forms of divination in the world, and its use has been recorded in Norfolk, Suffolk, Denmark, and Iceland well into the 19th century. Early modern belief treated eggs as symbols of life. To boil them violently in cold water – an inversion of nature – could signify the violent ending of life. Sailors’ lore attached meaning to stirring water to influence waves. To a frightened or grieving community, the act could appear as mimicry of the storm itself.
King’s Lynn and Its Witch
Lynn was used to suspicion. Ports were full of strangers; disease and vice were blamed on outsiders or awkward locals. The town’s Tuesday Market Place housed the gallows. Margaret Read, executed in 1590, was said to have had her heart burst from her body. Whether any part of that description is true matters less than the atmosphere it conveyed. Executions were civic theatre and moral reassurance.
Mother Gabley’s trial does not survive in the records we can consult today. The Wells entry asserts that she was apprehended and executed, and local histories follow that lead, assuming hanging in Lynn. Borough papers for the 1580s are incomplete, and assize files for Norfolk survive only patchily. If a prosecution took place it would have been before the county assizes, probably on a straightforward indictment of killing through witchcraft under the 1563 statute. Yet we lack depositions, witness accounts or sentencing records that would allow a historian to trace events in detail.
Interestingly, H.J.Hillen claims that Gabley was never executed in Lynn (although successfuly tried). He writes that she escaped “through the good-natured stupidity of Richard Clarck, our adle-pated Mayor”. One possible interpretation is that the Mayor didn’t agree with the verdict and allowed Mother Gabley to get away.
The Problem of Evidence
This silence forces us to read the Wells register carefully. Burial entries occasionally include moral commentary. Clergy sometimes attributed plague or sudden death to divine judgement. In that light, the Gabley remark may capture righteous commentary rather than proof of a judicial process. On the other hand, the fact that the writer thought it necessary to note execution suggests the story had traction beyond gossip.
Norfolk saw relatively few prosecutions under the 1563 law before the frenzy of the 1640s. That makes the Gabley case potentially significant, if only because it may mark one of the county’s first uses of the statute.
How the Legend Grew
What is traceable is the afterlife of the story. Nineteenth-century antiquarians repeated the register’s words. Twentieth-century guidebooks turned the eggs into iconography. Norfolk folklore podcasts still discuss the case as an example of East Anglian storm magic. Tuesday Market Place ghost tours pair her with later tales such as the Witch’s Heart carving linked with Margaret Read.
Modern readers are left with a story that sits on a balance point between archive and imagination. It illustrates how a single, theatrical detail – eggs boiling in cold water – can fire collective memory. That detail also matches practices known in European folk magic, where eggs were used for divination, healing or malign purposes. Yet evidence that Mother Gabley consciously performed magic is no stronger than the register’s own line.
Where Next?
The Norfolk Record Office catalogue holds the Wells register (Norfolk Record Office, reference PD 679/1, folio 43). Assize calendars, though fragmentary, may still hold traces. Borough minute books and ecclesiastical visitation papers sometimes record notorious figures in passing. It remains possible that a lost or unindexed document once told more of her story.
For now, Mother Gabley sits half-shadowed on the edge of Lynn’s history. She may have been an elderly woman seen at her chores, transformed by coincidence and fear into a witch. Or she may have been the focus of a formal prosecution whose paperwork simply did not endure. Either way her tale speaks to how communities cope with loss: when the sea takes men without reason, myth provides one.
If you visit Tuesday Market Place today, surrounded by pubs and traffic, there is nothing to show that a gallows once stood there. The Wells register survives, however, and its curt line reminds us that stories of witches were never merely folklore. They were shaped from grief, law and belief, and for at least one woman in 1583, they may have had fatal consequences.
© James Rye 2025
Book a Walk with a Trained and Qualified King’s Lynn Guide Through Historic Lynn
Further Reading
- Bever, Edward. The Realities of Witchcraft and Popular Magic in Early Modern Europe: Culture, Cognition, and Everyday Life. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.
- Briggs, Robin. Witches and Neighbours: The Social and Cultural Context of European Witchcraft. 2nd ed. Oxford: Blackwell, 2002.
- Gaskill, Malcolm. Witchfinders: A Seventeenth-Century English Tragedy. London: John Murray, 2005.
- Hillen, Henry, James. The History of King’s Lynn Vol.II. 1907.
- Norfolk Record Office. “Mother Gabley.” Blog post. [PD 679/1 reference noted].
- Rye, James. Spells, Suspicion, and Sentences: English Witchraft Laws, 2024.